CEO Pulse Podcast EP 238 episode thumbnail

EP 238 | Hot Leads for Real Estate Investors with James Heartquist

July 15, 2026•18 min read

CEO Pulse Podcast | Interview

Jul 15, 2026 · 1:06:48 · Hosted by Rafael Cortez

TL;DR

In EP 238 of the CEO Pulse Podcast, host Rafael Cortez talks with James Heartquist of Property Leads about pay per lead marketing for real estate investors. James explains how opt in seller leads are qualified, why most live transfers go unanswered, how title transfer data shows where deals are lost, and why sales skill matters more than lead source.

What you will learn in this episode

  • How pay per lead works at Property Leads, from web form to live transfer
  • Which seller answers James Heartquist treats as the strongest signs a lead will sell
  • Why speed to lead, clean phone numbers and a CRM decide who wins the deal
  • How title transfer data shows whether the leads or the sales process fell short
  • What budget and mindset James says an investor needs before buying leads
  • Why Rafael Cortez and James both say to keep your job while you learn to sell

How does James Heartquist say investors should turn pay per lead leads into deals?

Who is James Heartquist?

Rafael Cortez introduces James Heartquist as the brains behind the operation at Property Leads, a pay per lead company that sells inbound seller leads to real estate investors. Rafael says lead generation is one of the hardest pain points in any vertical, and that after more than 15 years in real estate he still sees it as one of the toughest things to conquer. He tells James that Property Leads is the only pay per lead service he recommends when people ask, because of the feedback he gets from his students.

James got into real estate around 2018 the way many investors do. He read Rich Dad Poor Dad, started listening to the BiggerPockets podcast and joined a real estate education program. He tried creative finance deals, but he realized he did not love the idea of scaling a house buying company. He wanted rentals over the long haul, so he started building a website to attract organic SEO leads as a side project.

How did James Heartquist end up at Property Leads?

While learning SEO, James heard an investor named Andy on a podcast talking about getting 60 to 80 SEO leads a month in the DC and Virginia markets. James was getting about one lead every two or three months, so he tracked Andy down on Facebook and they became friends.

By 2022 James was back on a W2 job running large construction projects. Andy started asking about his goals, and James learned that Andy had been quietly building Property Leads. James could speak the investor language and understood the lead side, so he was brought on to handle sales and retention. For a while he worked construction by day and made sales calls for three to five hours each night, until the team asked him to come on full time.

James says everyone at Property Leads takes product quality personally, because at some point they were all burned by someone in the real estate space. Rafael agrees that the companies that do well in this vertical tend to come from it.

How does pay per lead work at Property Leads?

James says every lead Property Leads generates starts with a form fill somewhere, so every lead is an opt in. Over the years the team has learned which web form questions predict whether a seller is likely to sell. Timeline is the biggest indicator, and a fast timeline plus some kind of motivation usually means something real is going on.

Rafael compares this to the four pillars he has used for years to prequalify sellers: condition, timeline, motivation and price. He says many investors skip the discovery conversation and go straight for the price, while Property Leads screens leads as they come in.

Most of that screening happens in the web form. If the team is not sure a seller really wants to sell, they send an extra confirmation such as asking the seller to reply one for yes or two for no. Organic SEO leads usually go straight out because those sellers are already primed. James adds that Property Leads keeps the buy box broad. A good lead is a seller who wants to sell in the next six months; if not, the investor is owed a refund.

Why do so many investors miss live transfers?

After a seller submits a form, a thank you page invites them to call right away, and Property Leads live transfers that call to the investor. James says about 25 percent of the leads they sell turn into a live transfer, and fewer than 20 percent of those transfers are answered. Some accounts sit near zero, while others answer 70 to 80 percent of the time.

Rafael is blunt about this. Investors pay thousands of dollars for leads and then do not pick up the phone. People are afraid of the conversation and afraid of making the offer, and they get creative about avoiding both. He asks listeners to be honest with themselves about whether they are in alignment with doing the business.

James says the person who does a little more than everyone else wins. Simply answering the phone puts you ahead. Rafael adds that if you are off for the night or the weekend, you should pause your lead flow in the dashboard instead of letting leads go unanswered.

What separates investors who convert leads?

James calls follow up the biggest needle mover. Speed to lead matters because a seller usually fills out two to three web forms. He also warns about numbers being flagged as spam likely, which can happen on one carrier and not another. Property Leads pays a company to monitor and fix its numbers every month. Rafael explains why swapping numbers is a bad fix: his CRM has follow up sequences that have run for eight to 12 months, and changing the number kills that rapport with sellers who were waiting until they were ready.

James says about half of the people who buy leads from Property Leads do not have a CRM. Add real follow up to answering the phone and you are already doing far more than the next investor.

He shares a story from a former team member who wholesaled for ten years and said that if he is paying $300 for a lead, he should not have to door knock. James agreed in principle, but told him that if it is the two of them competing, James is going to door knock and is more likely to win the deal. Rafael adds that sellers usually contact several companies, so you still have to put in the work. Expecting the lead to close itself, he says, is entitlement, and someone hungrier will beat you.

How does title transfer data show where deals are lost?

When Rafael asks about conversion rates, James says he hesitates to answer because conversion depends on the investor. A strong closer can monetize 20 average leads, while someone who is not there yet can get 20 great leads and still find a way not to get a deal.

The number that tells the story is the title transfer percentage: how many of the leads Property Leads sold you went on to sell the house to someone. If five of 40 leads changed hands within 30 days, the question becomes how much you offered and where you fell off in the sales process. James says the target is roughly 20 to 40 percent depending on the market. Even then, one investor with a 20 percent title transfer rate can be crushing it on return on ad spend while another at 40 percent only gets one and a half to two times their spend.

Exit strategy explains part of the gap. In a market like San Diego, many sellers are more financially comfortable and will list on the MLS, so investors there need a way to convert those leads, such as a referral to an agent or another option.

What is new at Property Leads?

James says the team keeps improving live transfers based on client feedback. When an investor misses a transfer, Property Leads now sends a text with the seller's name and address telling the investor to call right away. They are also rolling out what they call a home seller experience, after an experienced operator told them to treat the seller like a client too. Now the thank you page names the investor as the home buying specialist the seller can call, so the handoff feels familiar instead of like a stranger calling.

James learned why from a mobile locksmith who won his business by acknowledging he was a stranger and offering to come look before quoting a price. Sellers get nervous after filling out a form too, and those nerves are just sales objections to handle.

Inside the company, James says the team grew from three U.S. based employees to about 22 in the U.S. and roughly 10 outside it. Sales and marketing take turns being the bottleneck. Rafael compares it to rebuilding his 1961 Willys CJ5: drop in a bigger engine and the transmission or transfer case becomes the next thing to fix.

Property Leads also began as organic SEO only, betting that investors would love quality over quantity. Clients wanted more volume, so the team added paid channels. James says they test a new source with 20 or fewer leads, watch refunds and the lead ratings in the dashboard, and cut sources that do not perform.

Who is the ideal Property Leads customer?

James positions Property Leads as a premium service. If you are brand new with about $100 a month, it is probably not a fit yet. He suggests at least $1,500 a month and mentally preparing to keep that budget for six to 12 months, because even an experienced cold caller faces bottlenecks when switching channels. The ideal client also gives feedback, good and bad, and treats Property Leads as a growth partner instead of an adversary. Buying a couple of leads to test it out, he says, is one foot in the door.

Rafael says he does not recommend anything without evidence behind it, and he tells brand new students in his mentorship not to worry about the best leads yet because they cannot close them. They first have to learn how the conversation works, the seller's pain points and the solutions a wholesaler can offer. He pushes back hard when brand new investors want to spend $15,000 on paid ads before the skill set is there.

Rafael explains that people with a sales background come in with less fear of rejection. With people who have no sales background, the habit he most often has to retrain is telling sellers what they want to hear instead of anchoring to the numbers a wholesale deal needs. They agree that locking a deal up too high only leads to a second conversation asking for a price reduction, which wastes everyone's time and does not help the seller.

Should you quit your job to get into wholesaling?

James asks Rafael whether people should quit their jobs. Rafael says to transition, without question, because you do not know yet whether you will like the work. Success is not about IQ, he says, but about tenacity and alignment. He also pushes back on the stigma that wholesalers take advantage of sellers. If people could sell their properties on the MLS, they would, but houses that need a roof, are tear downs or are hoarder homes need a different solution. He recommends testing the business until you are doing one to three deals a month before leaving a job.

James says he was the one who quit his job, convinced he would be rich in six months with no sales background, and it was a hard time. Both men describe how sales becomes fun once you stop treating it as life or death.

Rafael shares that when he started, he was working on a psychology master's degree and running four to five face to face appointments a day while working for Sean Terry. He had been a firefighter, not a salesperson, and studying behavioral profiles made each appointment interesting.

Why chase the skill set instead of the money?

James says goal setting that starts with a dollar figure often makes people feel like failures a few months in. At Property Leads he learned to chase skill instead: he asks Andy what three things he needs to get better at, then goes and gets good at them, and the money follows. Rafael agrees. He spent plenty of time in survival mode watching the number, and once he started enjoying the process and building skills, the number changed as a byproduct.

Asked what he would tell his 17 year old self, James says to get into sales at 18 and get really good at it as fast as possible. Rafael adds that sales puts you in rooms with people who have a growth mindset, and James notes that sales is a skill you can take anywhere if one opportunity dries up. James invites listeners to email him at Property Leads to continue the conversation.

Key takeaways

  • Timeline is the strongest lead signal. James Heartquist says a fast timeline plus motivation is the best sign a seller will sell.
  • Answer the phone. Fewer than 20 percent of Property Leads live transfers are answered, so simply picking up puts an investor ahead.
  • Follow up beats new leads. About half of lead buyers have no CRM, and Rafael Cortez warns that changing phone numbers kills months of rapport.
  • Title transfer data tells the truth. Comparing your leads to the houses that actually sold shows whether the leads or your sales process fell short.
  • Budget for the long game. James suggests at least $1,500 a month for six to 12 months and treating the lead company as a growth partner.
  • Skill before spend. Rafael tells new investors in his mentorship to learn the seller conversation before buying premium leads.
  • Chase skill, not the number. Both say the money follows once you focus on getting better instead of watching the dollar figure.

Quotes from the conversation

“So if you can just do this one thing better than everybody else, just pick up the phone when somebody calls.”

James Heartquist, 14:30

“We can make any lead source good as long as we remove enough of the nonsense”

James Heartquist, 37:03

“We're not taking advantage, we're creating a solution for somebody who can't have another solution.”

Rafael Cortez, 55:42

“I stopped chasing the dollar and started chasing the skill set.”

James Heartquist, 59:08

Episode chapters

0:00Why lead generation takes a village
1:34From construction to cofounding Property Leads
8:38How pay per lead and prequalification work
11:47Why most live transfers go unanswered
15:08Speed to lead, spam flags and follow up
21:15Title transfer rates and conversion
26:29Home seller experience and the locksmith story
29:12Growing the team and fixing bottlenecks
43:25The ideal customer and learning to sell
54:28Keep your job, chase the skill set, and advice to his younger self

Who is on this episode?

James Heartquist

James Heartquist is a cofounder and operations lead at Property Leads, a pay per lead company that delivers inbound seller leads to real estate investors through organic SEO and paid advertising. He worked in construction for most of his career and got into real estate investing around 2018 before joining Property Leads in sales and retention.

About the host: Rafael Cortez

Rafael Cortez is the host of the CEO Pulse Podcast, an Organizational Psychologist and a real estate broker and investor based in Phoenix, Arizona. Raised in Yuma, Arizona, he became one of the youngest firefighters in Yuma County at 19 and launched his first business at 21. He has been involved in more than 1,300 real estate deals since 2009 and teaches the L.E.S.S. Business philosophy: Lean, Effective, Strategic, Simple. Rafael is the founder of CEO Pulse, Pulse Realty and Pulse Capital and the creator of REI Pulse CRM, and he mentors wholesalers in group and 1 on 1 settings. Read Rafael Cortez’s full bio.

Questions and answers

Who is James Heartquist?

James Heartquist is a cofounder and operations lead at Property Leads, a pay per lead company for real estate investors. He spent his career in construction, got into investing around 2018 and joined Property Leads in sales and retention before going full time.

What is pay per lead for real estate investors?

Pay per lead means an investor buys individual seller leads instead of running all the marketing alone. James Heartquist says every Property Leads lead comes from a seller filling out a web form, so each one is an opt in, and the leads are generated through organic SEO and paid ads.

How does Property Leads qualify seller leads?

Most qualification happens through web form questions. James Heartquist says timeline is the biggest indicator, and a fast timeline plus motivation suggests a real chance to buy. When the team is unsure, it sends an extra confirmation asking the seller to reply yes or no.

What counts as a good lead at Property Leads?

James Heartquist says a good lead is a seller who wants to sell within the next six months. If the seller does not, the investor is owed a refund. Property Leads keeps the buy box broad, so investors with very narrow criteria may do better pulling their own lists.

How often do investors answer live transfers?

Fewer than 20 percent of live transfers are answered, according to James Heartquist, and about 25 percent of leads become a live transfer. Some accounts answer almost none and others answer 70 to 80 percent. Rafael Cortez says investors who are off for the night should pause their lead flow instead of missing calls.

What is a title transfer rate in pay per lead?

A title transfer rate is the share of leads you bought whose houses actually sold to someone. James Heartquist says it shows whether the leads were weak or the investor fell off in the sales process. Property Leads generally targets 20 to 40 percent, depending on the market.

How much should an investor budget for pay per lead?

James Heartquist suggests at least $1,500 a month and preparing to hold that budget for six to 12 months. He says someone with about $100 a month is probably not a fit yet, and that even experienced cold callers hit bottlenecks when they switch channels.

Should new wholesalers buy premium leads right away?

Rafael Cortez tells brand new students in his mentorship not to worry about the best leads yet because they cannot close them. He says new investors should first learn how the seller conversation works, the pain points and the solutions a wholesaler can offer.

Should you quit your job to start wholesaling?

Rafael Cortez says to transition, not quit, because you do not know yet whether you will like the work. He suggests testing the business until you are doing one to three deals a month. James Heartquist says he quit his own job too early with no sales skills and it was a hard time.

What advice would James Heartquist give his 17 year old self?

James Heartquist would tell his younger self to get into sales at 18 and get really good at it as fast as possible. He says sales is a skill you can take anywhere if one opportunity dries up, and Rafael Cortez adds that it puts you around people with a growth mindset.

Build your business on systems

Rafael Cortez built REI Pulse CRM from the systems he runs his own deals on. See how it works for wholesalers and investors.

Explore REI Pulse

Browse every CEO Pulse Podcast episode · About Rafael Cortez · YouTube · Apple Podcasts · Spotify

blog author avatar

Rafael Cortez

Rafael Cortez is an Organizational Psychologist, real estate broker and investor, founder of CEO Pulse and REI Pulse, and host of the CEO Pulse Podcast.

Back to Blog