CEO Pulse Podcast | Mindset Monday
TL;DR
In EP 197 of the CEO Pulse Podcast Mindset Monday series, Rafael Cortez and co host Justin Thorstad talk about breaking free from the false stories we tell ourselves. They explain how assumptions grow into resistance, resentment and revenge, why leaders need open conversations, how to write out a trigger and how to spot an old story.
What you will learn in this episode
- Why the mind makes up stories based on assumptions
- The three R's: resistance, resentment and revenge
- What a lost phone taught Rafael Cortez's son about worry
- How to clear a trigger with a conversation or by writing it out
- Why leaders need people to feel safe bringing up issues
- How to recognize when you are running an old story
How do you break free from the false stories you tell yourself?
What are the false stories we tell ourselves?
Rafael Cortez, host of the CEO Pulse Podcast and an Organizational Psychologist, opens this Mindset Monday episode with co host Justin Thorstad on the false stories we tell ourselves. He notes the common saying that most of what we worry about never happens, yet it takes up free rent in our heads. As entrepreneurs juggle growth, business and many roles, they create stories that feel real but are backed by nothing but assumptions. Those stories can cause damage and steal opportunities.
Justin Thorstad says he sees the same thing in his organization, with people making up stories about unrelated events. That is simply what the mind does: constant chatter built from old and often inaccurate reference points. He asks when a story you made up without asking questions ever turned out to be right and helpful. Almost never. So the real question is not why you made up a story, but what stopped you from opening your mouth to ask questions and get the facts.
Rafael Cortez describes how that noise becomes a soap opera in our heads. Why did I not get that promotion? Why did that venture fail? Why did that seller not come through? We attach individual events to a series of beliefs that are just internal chatter, and it creates a false sense of reality.
What are the three R's of a false story?
Justin Thorstad says these stories rob you of attention. An event happens that means nothing, but the mind decides what it means and keeps adding layers. First comes resistance to the event. Then, because of the story you have built, resentment toward the person or situation, and you start playing the victim. It is their fault. But it is really you listening to the story and feeding it attention, all while never asking a question.
The third R is revenge. In organizations, that can look like people leaving, spreading rumors or speaking badly about others. The only payoff is that the person who made up the story gets to feel right and victimized, even though it was all, as Rafael Cortez puts it, fake news happening in our brain.
What did a lost phone teach Rafael Cortez about worry?
Rafael Cortez shares a recent moment with his 12 year old son. One school morning, his son could not find his phone and had a complete meltdown. Usually a positive kid, he started speaking in absolutes, saying everything always goes wrong, and built an elaborate story about how he would not have a phone after the bus dropped him off and could not call anyone.
Rafael Cortez told him it was a very creative story and reminded him that most of what we worry about in life will probably never happen. They searched for about 15 seconds and found the phone, and the whole story that had created chaos faded away.
It was a reminder for Rafael Cortez too. He tries to be intentional about which thoughts he lets take over, but everyone gets pulled down a rabbit hole sometimes, losing 15 or 20 minutes to a made up story. Justin Thorstad jokes that most people are just getting warmed up at that point.
How do false stories cost you opportunities?
Rafael Cortez says the lost phone was a small story. The bigger ones grow because we avoid a difficult conversation, assume someone should already know, or believe we are being isolated or attacked. He sees this in workplaces all the time. A simple, practical conversation with someone else, or even with yourself, can resolve what hours of emotional speculation cannot.
Justin Thorstad believes most people spend hours a day adding layers to stories to make them feel justified. Imagine redirecting that attention to something positive and forward moving. People avoid direct conversations because they fear retaliation, but saying what happened, how you felt and asking what the other person intended is simply mature communication.
Why Rafael Cortez stopped bottling things up
Rafael Cortez says he dislikes the victim route because he used to live there. Growing up, he kept things bottled in and let ugly stories fester instead of saying what he was thinking and wanted. He asks listeners: what stories are you telling yourself, and how are they affecting your life and results? Are you leaning toward victim thinking instead of having an honest conversation that could resolve it in five minutes?
How do you clear a trigger before it builds?
Justin Thorstad shares that as a child he had no voice, so he learned to suppress everything. As an adult, resistance built into resentment until he exploded, and of course it never happened at the right time or with the right person. That is displaced aggression, and it is unhealthy for any relationship. He realized there is no virtue in having a large capacity to store frustration.
Letting it go does not mean forgetting it happened, because ignoring it only means you will trip over it later. Justin Thorstad started having a conversation at the first sign of resistance, before the energy could build. When the charge is small, you can speak objectively, ask better questions, get answers and move on. When it is big, the other person senses it and becomes defensive.
Rafael Cortez adds that the difference is being proactive instead of reactive. Pause, check yourself, collect yourself and apply critical thinking. You will still get triggered, because ego is part of being human, but it does not have to control you. Focus on the outcome you actually want.
Write it out first
Justin Thorstad says he swung from bottling things up to discharging immediately, which did not work either. Now he writes it out, even in a notes app on his phone: what he is experiencing, what he feels and what he wants to say. His first draft usually comes out as anger, so he restates it objectively, because attacking, blaming or shaming will not lead to resolution. Writing helps him see how much of it is a story, find the real question and identify what he is truly upset about. Rafael Cortez agrees that if we care about something, we have to make an intentional effort to understand it.
Why do leaders need people to feel safe speaking up?
Justin Thorstad stresses that as the CEO or visionary, if you bottle things up or explode instantly, your team will associate conversations with you as scary. That is not a healthy culture. You want people to feel safe bringing you issues, problems and unmet expectations, because honesty and authenticity build relationships and make people want to stay.
Rafael Cortez adds that it creates transparency. The last thing you want is your own people unable to open up because you are stuck in stories that keep you reactive.
Both agree it goes beyond business. Justin Thorstad says people believe they show up differently at work than at home, but what you do in one place is what you do everywhere. It is a mental model you operate from in your business, your relationships, your parenting and your friendships.
How do you rewrite a story driven by fear?
Justin Thorstad shares a recent session with a client. He asked what kept her from leaving her comfort zone. She was operating from a predictable past while expecting an elevated future. Her answer was fear of the unknown. Justin Thorstad invited her to inspect that story. If you create a story focused on loss and everything that could go wrong, why not focus on the opposite? It is not a risk of losing everything; it is an opportunity to gain what you want, with all the excitement of something new. If you are going to make up stories anyway, make up one about what could go right.
Rafael Cortez acknowledges that we are wired to survive, not to be optimistic. When something like a market downturn happens, we create stories, assumptions, judgments and reactions. But that does not mean we cannot intentionally switch how our stories work.
Justin Thorstad agrees that negativity is the default setting many of us inherited. That explains why we do it, but it is not an excuse to keep doing it. With awareness, you can ask what an upgrade looks like and practice it.
How do you recognize when you are running an old story?
Justin Thorstad says the process is simple. Your feelings are the cue. If you do not feel good, you are likely thinking lower, negative thoughts and going victim. Notice it, recognize that you are making up a story, and choose differently by opening your mouth to validate it. He adds that intuition is different from a story of the mind, which is a separate conversation. Most fears are false evidence appearing real. If you keep doing what you have always done, you cannot expect different results.
Rafael Cortez asks how to recognize a story in the moment. Justin Thorstad says he notices how effortless it feels. That is old programming he practiced for decades, so it takes no conscious effort. If he is not directing his mind proactively, he is running on habit. Few people were programmed well in childhood, so if you are not working on yourself, you default to the old patterns.
Choose change instead of being forced
Justin Thorstad says many people only change when they have no choice. That is not powerful. Volunteering to change because you want deeper relationships and better results is a true choice, and it gives you permission to make mistakes along the way. Rafael Cortez calls it a very empowering space. Justin Thorstad notes you can move away from what you do not want or toward what you do want, and moving toward it feels far better and opens more options.
Why do unspoken expectations damage relationships?
Rafael Cortez contrasts stories with a hypothesis. A hypothesis is an educated guess backed by data. The stories he means are a single event turned into a laundry list of reasons people dislike you or why you will fail.
Justin Thorstad adds that once you identify with a story, it becomes the filter for everything you perceive. The eyes can only see what the mind expects to see, so you look for evidence to prove it. One of the most damaging stories is the unspoken expectation: you should have known. No one is a mind reader. Say what you need.
Rafael Cortez's advice: stay out of story, have real conversations and challenge assumptions as they pop up. Do not look for validation of negative stories, because the reticular activating system will draw you toward whatever you are programmed to see. Justin Thorstad closes with the payoff. When you verify and validate, you can take away the lessons objectively, and that is wisdom you carry forward.
Key takeaways
- Stories are assumptions. Most stories we tell ourselves have no facts behind them.
- Watch the three R's. Unchecked stories grow into resistance, resentment and revenge.
- Ask before you assume. A five minute conversation can resolve what hours of worry cannot.
- Clear triggers early. Address resistance while it is small so you can speak objectively.
- Write it out. Writing helps separate the story from the real question.
- Leaders set the tone. Teams need to feel safe raising issues and unmet expectations.
- Effortless can mean old. If a reaction feels automatic, it is likely an old story running.
Quotes from the conversation
“I notice how effortless I'm operating to have it, which means it's the old programming.”
Justin Thorstad, 23:05
“What you do here is what you do there is what you do everywhere.”
Justin Thorstad, 17:49
“The eyes can only see and the ears can only hear what the mind expects to see”
Justin Thorstad, 26:31
“I think the difference too comes when we're being reactive, as opposed to proactive”
Rafael Cortez, 13:26
Episode chapters
| 0:57 | The false stories we tell ourselves |
| 4:08 | Resistance, resentment and revenge |
| 4:54 | A lost phone and a big story |
| 7:59 | Stories that cost opportunities |
| 11:04 | From bottling up to clearing energy |
| 15:03 | Writing it out |
| 15:53 | Why leaders need safe conversations |
| 18:15 | Rewriting fear stories |
| 21:21 | Recognizing an old story |
| 26:48 | Unspoken expectations |
Who is on this episode?
Justin Thorstad
Justin Thorstad is Rafael Cortez's co host on the Mindset Monday series of the CEO Pulse Podcast. In this episode Justin explains how to catch false stories early, clear triggers and turn assumptions into wisdom.
About the host: Rafael Cortez
Rafael Cortez is the host of the CEO Pulse Podcast, an Organizational Psychologist and a real estate broker and investor based in Phoenix, Arizona. Raised in Yuma, Arizona, he became one of the youngest firefighters in Yuma County at 19 and launched his first business at 21. He has been involved in more than 1,300 real estate deals since 2009 and mentors entrepreneurs through the L.E.S.S. Business philosophy: Lean, Effective, Strategic, Simple. Rafael is the founder of CEO Pulse, Pulse Realty and Pulse Capital and the creator of REI Pulse CRM, and he mentors wholesalers in group and 1 on 1 settings. Read Rafael Cortez’s full bio.
Questions and answers
What are false stories?
Rafael Cortez describes false stories as narratives we create in our heads that feel real but are backed only by assumptions. They take up attention and can steal opportunities.
What are the three R's of a false story?
Justin Thorstad says unchecked stories move from resistance to resentment and finally to revenge. Each step adds layers while the person never asks a clarifying question.
How did Rafael Cortez help his son with a false story?
When his 12 year old son panicked over a lost phone, Rafael Cortez called it a creative story and reminded him most worries never happen. They found the phone in about 15 seconds.
Why do people avoid difficult conversations?
Justin Thorstad says people fear retaliation or conflict. Yet stating what happened, how you felt and asking about the other person's intention is simply mature communication.
How do you clear a trigger before it explodes?
Justin Thorstad has a conversation at the first sign of resistance, while the emotional charge is small. That lets him speak objectively and ask better questions.
Why write out what you are feeling?
Justin Thorstad writes out his reaction, then restates it objectively. It shows him how much is a story, what his real question is and what he is truly upset about.
How do false stories affect company culture?
Justin Thorstad says leaders who bottle up or explode make conversations feel scary. Teams need to feel safe raising issues, which builds transparency and loyalty.
How do you turn a fear story around?
Justin Thorstad suggests focusing on the opposite of the fear. If you are going to make up a story, make up one about what could go right.
How do you know you are running an old story?
Justin Thorstad says your feelings are the cue, and an old story feels effortless because you practiced it for years. When that happens, open your mouth and validate the story.
Why are unspoken expectations so damaging?
Justin Thorstad says expecting people to just know what you want sets them up to fail. Nobody is a mind reader, so state your needs clearly.
Related episodes
Build your business on systems
Rafael Cortez built REI Pulse CRM from the systems he runs his own deals on. See how it works for wholesalers and investors.
Explore REI PulseBrowse every CEO Pulse Podcast episode · About Rafael Cortez · YouTube · Apple Podcasts · Spotify

