CEO Pulse Podcast EP 174 episode thumbnail

EP 174 | Mindset: Real Estate Disruption with Rafael Cortez, Justin Thorstad and Ted Bland

August 21, 2023

CEO Pulse Podcast | Mindset Monday

Aug 21, 2023 · 48:25 · Hosted by Rafael Cortez

TL;DR

In this CEO Pulse Podcast Mindset Monday episode, Rafael Cortez, co host Justin Thorstad and Arizona realtor Ted Bland break down the 2023 buyer broker compensation lawsuits. They cover the mindset, legal, tactical and marketing sides of industry disruption and why agents who prepare early win whether or not the change arrives.

What you will learn in this episode

  • What the 2023 buyer broker compensation lawsuits signaled for agents
  • The four levels of preparing for disruption: mindset, tactical, legal and marketing
  • Why initiating beats reacting or even responding
  • Why buyer broker agreements and listings matter more in a changing market
  • How to learn from markets where the change already happened

How should real estate agents handle industry disruption?

What was happening with the buyer broker compensation lawsuits?

Rafael Cortez, host of the CEO Pulse Podcast and an Organizational Psychologist, welcomes a special guest to this Mindset Monday episode with co host Justin Thorstad: Ted Bland, an Arizona realtor who had been listening to the show for about a year and once sparked a whole episode with a question. Rafael Cortez explains that industry wide disruptions do not happen often, but when they do, they hit your mindset and your pockets. The topic in summer 2023 was the lawsuits over buyer broker compensation.

Ted Bland, who had been following the cases closely, gives the background. In 2019, two major lawsuits were filed against the National Association of Realtors, one in Illinois and one in Missouri. Smaller copycat suits followed, including one in Massachusetts where plaintiffs sued their local MLS. On June 30, that MLS agreed to a settlement, dropping the requirement that sellers offer compensation to the buyer's broker. A major industry consultancy then published an open letter telling brokers to prepare agents for buyer broker agreements and for listing agents working with unrepresented buyers.

Why could this change affect buyers and agents so much?

Rafael Cortez points out that buyers already carry more upfront costs than sellers, so adding a broker fee changes affordability. Justin Thorstad adds that many buyers would go straight to the listing agent, which creates a puzzle: how do you work with someone without representing them? In Arizona, agents must use the state association forms, the public does not have access to them, and helping an unrepresented buyer can create implied agency. Justin Thorstad calls it double the work for half the pay, and notes the irony that the sellers suing had no problem when the fee covered their own purchase.

Rafael Cortez says the investment world is used to creative deal structures and collaboration, but the traditional side has done things one way for a long time. He asks how an agent stays centered when a wrench gets thrown into a craft they worked hard to master.

Why do Justin Thorstad and Ted Bland see disruption as opportunity?

Justin Thorstad says he loves change, especially when it shows up without his consent. When you have a pulse on your craft, you see change coming and have time to reposition. He expects a shift like this to thin out part time agents, which creates more business for the rest. In any market shift, he says, wealth does not disappear; it transfers to the people who saw it coming.

Ted Bland lays out four levels of preparation: the mindset, the tactical side such as how to handle an unrepresented buyer, the legal side of avoiding implied agency, and the marketing opportunity. Change means agents must re educate the consumer, and that re education is a huge marketing opportunity for anyone willing to take it. Rafael Cortez relates it to his wholesale business, where deals fell through when the market shifted the year before. Instead of panicking, his team went back to education and set clear expectations with sellers.

React, respond or initiate?

Justin Thorstad describes three levels. You can react and freak out, or you can stay calm and respond. The most powerful level is to initiate: make videos and educate the public now, before the change. He cites an NAR survey showing that the buying cycle from first idea to closing is about 24 months. Ted Bland adds that it should align with your core values, and if nothing changes, everyone who prepared is still light years ahead. Justin Thorstad calls it moving from salesy to leading with a servant mentality, and Ted Bland adds, to an educator.

What does step up or step out mean for agents?

Rafael Cortez says opportunity does not always show up as something flashy. Sometimes it looks confusing and cloudy, but you know something is there. The message he keeps hearing is step up or step out. Justin Thorstad agrees, saying at his brokerage, Libertas, they mentor agents up or out. He adds that most people wait until they are forced to change, then discover they were capable all along. You can wait and struggle, or position yourself now to serve others.

Rafael Cortez notes that when he is reactive, he is in survival mode, picking up pieces that already broke. Justin Thorstad warns that agents who wait until the decision is final will be behind while others take market share. Ted Bland shares a tsunami analogy: sailors take their boats out to sea before the wave, because the harbor is where boats get wrecked.

How can agents prepare tactically right now?

Justin Thorstad expects new models, from limited service brokerages to a menu of services. The more things change, the more they stay the same: it is still the same transaction. His brokerage already stopped dual agency, because representation means protecting your client, and you cannot play chess against yourself. Ted Bland adds that solo listing agents may struggle with an influx of unrepresented buyers unless they partner with a team.

Justin Thorstad says his brokerage uses a buyer consultation that ends with a request for exclusive representation, yet most agents never use a buyer broker agreement. You would not take a listing without an agreement, so why drive buyers around for free? His advice is to go get listings now and educate sellers. Whoever has the listings will attract the buyers. Rafael Cortez adds that this is the time to double down on your education, your skills and your value proposition.

Ted Bland suggests networking with agents in Massachusetts and in the Northwest MLS area, where the change already happened. Early reports showed about 80 to 90 percent of sellers there still offering compensation to the buyer's broker. Rafael Cortez notes the wholesale industry has seen similar shifts, including an Arizona disclosure rule for wholesalers. Ted Bland says he must prepare his sphere for difficult conversations, and Justin Thorstad adds that it takes the public about 90 days to absorb a major change. Rafael Cortez closes by saying entrepreneurs must adjust every day and lead with a problem solving mindset.

Key takeaways

  • Disruption transfers opportunity. Agents who see change coming position themselves to benefit.
  • Initiate, do not react. Educate consumers before the change takes effect.
  • Re education is marketing. Helping consumers understand change sets you apart.
  • Use agreements. Buyer broker agreements protect your time and clarify the relationship.
  • Learn from the source. Network with agents in markets where the change already happened.

Quotes from the conversation

“But that re-education is a huge marketing opportunity that just about anyone in the industry has if they choose to do it”

Ted Bland, 12:31

“You can fight the old model or you can create a new one that makes the old obsolete.”

Justin Thorstad, 27:03

“You can't play chess against yourself.”

Justin Thorstad, 27:37

Episode chapters

1:43When an industry gets disrupted
3:51The buyer broker compensation lawsuits
7:09Affordability and implied agency
9:44Why change creates opportunity
15:14React, respond or initiate
18:17Step up or step out
25:16New brokerage models and dual agency
28:28Buyer broker agreements and listings
33:51Learning from markets already changing

Who is on this episode?

Justin Thorstad

Justin Thorstad is Rafael Cortez's co host on the Mindset Monday series of the CEO Pulse Podcast. This episode also features Ted Bland, an Arizona realtor and longtime listener who closely followed the buyer broker compensation lawsuits.

About the host: Rafael Cortez

Rafael Cortez is the host of the CEO Pulse Podcast, an Organizational Psychologist and a real estate broker and investor based in Phoenix, Arizona. Raised in Yuma, Arizona, he became one of the youngest firefighters in Yuma County at 19 and launched his first business at 21. He has been involved in more than 1,300 real estate deals since 2009 and mentors entrepreneurs through the L.E.S.S. Business philosophy: Lean, Effective, Strategic, Simple. Rafael is the founder of CEO Pulse, Pulse Realty and Pulse Capital and the creator of REI Pulse CRM, and he mentors wholesalers in group and 1 on 1 settings. Read Rafael Cortez’s full bio.

Questions and answers

What were the buyer broker compensation lawsuits about?

Ted Bland explains that lawsuits challenged the requirement that sellers pay the buyer's broker. A 2023 Massachusetts MLS settlement dropped that requirement and signaled change for the industry.

How should agents respond to industry disruption?

Justin Thorstad says the best move is to initiate rather than react. Educate consumers now so you are ahead whether or not the change happens.

What are the four levels of preparing for this change?

Ted Bland names mindset, tactical, legal and marketing. Re educating the consumer is the biggest marketing opportunity.

Why does Justin Thorstad push buyer broker agreements?

Justin Thorstad says an agreement clarifies the relationship and protects the agent's time. You would not take a listing without an agreement, so buyers deserve the same clarity.

What does step up or step out mean?

Rafael Cortez says disruption forces professionals to commit to their craft or leave. Those who step up find opportunity in the confusion.

How can agents learn from markets where the change already happened?

Ted Bland suggests networking with agents in Massachusetts and the Northwest MLS area. They can share what is working before the change spreads.

Build your business on systems

Rafael Cortez built REI Pulse CRM from the systems he runs his own deals on. See how it works for wholesalers and investors.

Explore REI Pulse

Browse every CEO Pulse Podcast episode · About Rafael Cortez · YouTube · Apple Podcasts · Spotify

blog author avatar

Rafael Cortez

Rafael Cortez is an Organizational Psychologist, real estate broker and investor, founder of CEO Pulse and REI Pulse, and host of the CEO Pulse Podcast.

Back to Blog